Tom Scott vs Forever21

When I found this nice rec­tan­gle top at Bar­neys I was like “hmm, great for sum­mer evening with jeans… but too expen­sive”. Sheer cot­ton blend three-quarter sleeve top with squared neck­line and side vents. Ribbed cuffs and hem. It looks very casual but styl­ish the same time. Then I was check­ing new arrivals at Forever21 and sur­prised by not less nicer but afford­able alter­na­tive top! This one has casual long sleeves and fea­tur­ing an all-over sheer burnout and ribbed knit trim. Compare:

Do you like it?